Recruiting Better podcast

From candidate-led to problem-led BD

Jamie Rogers stopped leading with candidates. He started leading with client problems. Here's how.

The episode

The conversation behind the shift

When the market Jamie worked in changed, the approach he had relied on stopped producing the same opportunities. Rather than simply repeat it in a different niche, he began looking for a more robust way to start conversations and develop client relationships.

In this episode, Jamie and Ben discuss what that change looked like in practice, from building a problem menu to approaching discovery and commercial terms differently.

From Pitching to Problem Solving in Recruitment Sales with Jamie RogersWatch on YouTube

Jamie's story

When hard work isn't enough on its own

Jamie describes his old approach to BD as a "foggy mess". He was working hard, building relationships and making placements, but the process was difficult to repeat and difficult to teach to a team.

As demand in his market fell, leading with candidates became less reliable. The question was no longer just how to work harder. It was how to give the right clients a reason to talk before they had a vacancy.

“I know I sound like nobody else.”
Jamie Rogers, Darwin

Jamie puts that difference down to understanding his market's problems and learning how to articulate them in his own words.

What changed

Three shifts worth stealing

  1. 01

    Start with problems worth talking about

    Jamie began by using common hiring frustrations: irrelevant CVs, candidates who looked strong on paper but disappointed in person, and offers lost to competing employers. They opened some conversations, but were most relevant when someone was already hiring.

    He went deeper by asking leaders about their pressures and frustrations, looking for recurring problems and connecting them to the commercial context of their market.

    Takeaway: A useful problem menu is researched and refined. It is not a generic list copied from another recruiter.

  2. 02

    Make discovery a business conversation

    Jamie's earlier client conversations focused on the role, salary and fee. His newer approach explores what the business is trying to achieve, what is getting in the way and where better hiring could make a difference.

    Takeaway: Understand the problem before deciding what solution, if any, makes sense.

  3. 03

    Put the commercial conversation on the same side of the table

    Jamie describes using an approach inspired by Todd Caponi's transparent negotiation framework. Instead of treating fee percentage as the only variable, both sides discussed what mattered to them, including payment, volume, communication and commitment.

    Takeaway: A good commercial agreement covers more than the headline fee. Make the trade-offs visible and work through them together.

Case study

What that looked like in a real pitch

Jamie describes a potential assignment involving 30 jobs across Europe. The client expected a conventional pitch. Instead, Jamie's team asked questions, explored frustrations and discussed the commercial terms collaboratively on a shared screen.

The team won the work. Jamie believes the way they showed up as consultants, rather than simply presenting their track record, was an important factor. He planned to ask the client for their perspective.

Free worksheet

Build your first problem menu

You don't need Jamie's exact problems. You need a better understanding of your own market. Use these prompts to collect and test what matters to the people you want to work with.

  1. Step 1

    Choose a specific group

    Who are you trying to help? Name the type of business and the person you want to speak to. A broad sector alone may not tell you enough.

  2. Step 2

    Gather the language

    Ask people in that market:

    • What's putting the most pressure on you at the moment?
    • What is frustrating you about building or managing your team?
    • What gets in the way of the results you're trying to achieve?
    • What have you already tried?
  3. Step 3

    Connect the problem to the business

    For each recurring issue, note:

    • Who experiences it?
    • What happens when it isn't solved?
    • Why might it matter even when there is no live vacancy?
    • What evidence do you have that this is a real problem, rather than an assumption?
  4. Step 4

    Test and refine

    Choose one problem, describe it in the client's language and use it to start a conversation. Listen to the response. Record what lands, what doesn't and what you need to understand better.

How a row looks. Illustrative example, not Jamie's market.
AudienceProblem in their wordsCommercial contextEvidenceQuestion to test next
A growing software team leader.Important work keeps being delayed because key technical responsibilities sit with too few people.Delivery depends on those individuals having the capacity to keep up.A hypothesis to discuss with relevant leaders, not a proven market-wide finding."Where is a lack of capacity making it hardest to deliver what you've planned?"

Get the worksheet in your inbox

The four steps plus a blank problem-menu grid, ready to fill in.

Team exercise

Ask this at your next team meeting

"If we couldn't mention a candidate or a current vacancy, what would we have to say that our ideal clients would still care about?"

Write down the answers. Which are based on real client conversations, and which are assumptions worth testing?

Next step

How dependable is your approach to BD?

Jamie changed the way he started and developed client conversations. If you're wondering where your own approach is working and where it needs attention, the BD Benchmark gives you a place to start.

Take the BD Benchmark

Related reading: Good at recruitment. So why is new business so hard?

Recruiting Better is hosted by Ben Browning, founder of Resonant.